2027 Overall Winner
Meineke Car Care Center
New Haven’s Top Choice for tire shops
- Rating
- 4.8
- Reviews
- 225
- Years
- –
“Highest overall score of the 19 businesses we reviewed for tire shops in New Haven: 4.8 stars from 225 reviews.”
Top Choice
New Haven · 2027 Tire shops Awards
5 winners selected from 19 businesses, plus 14 finalists worth a call.
Overall winner
New Haven’s Top Choice for tire shops in 2027
Award winners
Best in their field
Each award goes to the winner with the strongest record for that one thing, and every award states its reason.
2027 Winner
Midas
Winner
4.8 · 156 reviews · Branford
A 4.8-star record from 156 reviews, enough to place among New Haven’s winners.
2027 Winner
Star Tires Plus Wheels
Customer Choice
4.5 · 394 reviews · West Haven
The most-reviewed of this year’s winners, with 394 public reviews averaging 4.5 stars.
Also among the 2027 winners
Finalists
More tire shops in New Haven
14 more businesses that met every requirement. Any of them is a reasonable place to start.
East Rock Auto Repair Inc
New Haven
Monro Muffler Brake & Service
East Haven
Monro Auto Service and Tire Centers
Woodbridge
Whip-It Tire and Auto Repair
Branford
Meineke Car Care Center
New Haven
Amity Motors
Woodbridge
Porto's Tire Service
Hamden
Joanna's Truck Tire Service Llc
East Haven
Town Fair Tire
Branford
Lela and Matt's Car Care Clinic
Guilford
Access Auto Tires
New Haven
Aquila Motors
New Haven
United Tire Inc
Branford
Precision Wheel Service
North Branford
Request a quote
Ask New Haven’s winners for a quote
Tell us what you need once and choose which winners hear from you. It takes about two minutes.
Your request goes only to the businesses you tick. TopChoice never sells your details, and asking for a quote has no effect on any award.
Selection methodology
How winners are chosen
Nobody can enter or nominate themselves. Every business we can find that offers tire shops in New Haven is reviewed automatically.
- 19businesses met the minimum rating and review checks
- 14finalists who met every requirement
- 5winners, each with a stated award reason
- 0awards that were paid for or applied for
What counts, and how much
- Customer rating, adjusted for review count
- 30%
- Number of public reviews
- 20%
- Recent review activity
- 20%
- Years of local work
- 15%
- Complete, current business details
- 10%
- Checks we could confirm (license, insurance, identity)
- 5%
What doesn’t count
The highest overall score wins the Overall award. Each other award goes to the winner with the strongest record for that one thing, such as the most reviews or the longest track record.
Local facts
The New Haven market behind the awards
Public figures that show what tire shops here work with, and the rules every winner has to meet.
- 7,425
People per square mile
Calculated from U.S. Census Bureau 2025 estimates and Gazetteer land area, 2025 · official source
- 18.7 sq mi
Land area
U.S. Census Bureau, 2025 Gazetteer files, 2025 · official source
- 138,774
New Haven residents
U.S. Census Bureau, Vintage 2025 population estimates (sub-est2025), July 1, 2025 · official source
- +3.6%
Population change since 2020 (from 134,014 (April 2020 base))
U.S. Census Bureau, Vintage 2025 population estimates (sub-est2025), 2020–2025 · official source
Figures from public sources. Figures tagged “Sample figure” show what the live data feed will fill in; they are not real counts.
Questions
About the New Haven tire shops awards
- How were the 2027 tire shops winners in New Haven decided?
- Winners are chosen per category each edition from businesses with the strongest ratings, review history and record checks. We compared 19 tire shops for New Haven.
- Which of these tire shops in New Haven has the best reviews?
- Meineke Car Care Center has a 4.8 rating from 225 public reviews, the highest on this page.
- Which of these tire shops has the most reviews?
- Star Tires Plus Wheels, with 394 public reviews. A long review history shows how a business handles many jobs.
- Are these tire shops licensed?
- 5 of the 5 businesses here had their state license checked against public records. Each profile shows the source and the date of the check.
- How many quotes should I get for tire shops in New Haven?
- Get at least three. Use the quote form on this page: only the businesses you tick receive your request.
Spotted something wrong? Send a correction. We reply within two working days.
For winners
The official winner badge
A badge that proves itself
Each winner gets a badge kit on its winner profile, with copy-paste code. Every badge links back to its award page, so customers can check the award in one click, and it disappears if the award lapses.
For business owners
Being found is free.
Every business we can find that offers tire shops in New Haven is considered each year, whether or not it has heard of us. Claim your free profile so we judge you on the right phone number, website, hours and service area.
Already a winner?
Your winner badge and the link back to your award page are free. Optional extras never affect results.
More 2027 awards